I think that I received an old or used pair on my 1st order, but I reordered them and my reorder was a success. I love these boots that are glossy and fabulous. They are comfortable and run just a bit large in size, but they're perfect for wearing socks.Got these for the rain at school. My average size is a 6.5 -7 in shoes and I got these in a 6, so definitely size down. Overall the color and bottom grip of the shoe is great.These boots are solid, quality rainwear that will last forever if you taker proper care of it. I’ve discovered that treating the clean, dry boots with a UV protectant a couple of times a year has kept them looking like they’re still brand new.Can’t beat hunter rain bootsI wear a size 5.5 and ordered a 5 and they fit perfectly. There's even a to little toe room. I love the fit, color, and feel. The color is absolutely beautiful and I like how they don't just slide on and off too easily. I highly recommend.I wanted to wear these beautiful glossy boots so badly, but even though I ordered the short length they were still too small/tight around my calves which cause the rubber to bunch up around my ankles. It looked almost as if I didn’t pull them up all the way. I gave them to my niece and she LOVES them! Ladies with large calves, you may want to measure your calf and compare with the measurements listed in the description.Wore these today in a downpour and my feet stayed dry! You can see they are a bit dirty but it will wash right off. Great bootsI love the spearmint color to bring in spring! I recently slogged around in a marshy field doing Earth Day cleanup and my feet stayed warm and dry. Though I normally wear a 7.5, the 7 fits with the added Hunter boot socks. I am pleased with this product.I bought the wellingtons for my wife but unfortunately they were a very tight fit around her calf muscles and would rub so we returned them. What we had not been aware of was that they were supplied by International Amazon so we had to pay for shipment back to Slovakia and pay import duties on the return. Needless to say a very expensive return and will be more careful of who is full filling the shipment in the future.The wellingtons themselves looked great and of good quality so the poor rating is related to the returns which cosy us over £40.00.As with the "Long" version the adjustment buckle appears to be wholly cosmetic and would be better either without or better still, to provide some adjustment, as with some other manufacturers.Yet to prove that these are 100% waterproof as expected - didn't realise that some "fashion brands" could prove to be spectacularly unfunctional in this respect, so given reputation, I am hoping this will not be the case with these.Bought for my daughter in law - I am the same size and they are a good fit and the quality is what you would expect for these quality welly bobs. These where a bargain price the cheapest I could source by far, with absolutley no down issues. Box is perfect, product is perfect and fast delivery - u cant go wrongAs expected for genuine hunter wellingtons, they are of a high quality. For anyone who hasn’t had hunters before, They are snug to fit into initially as the width of most feet are wider than your ankle, so pretty difficult to get on initially. However they are roomy once fully on and so comfortable! I wear mine with genuine hunter boot socks which adds extra comfort and makes them more secure fitting around your foot. LOVE THEM!Not as good quality as boots I’ve had for years. Doubt whether they are thorn proof. Will think twice about buying Hunters again.